The Government Accountability Office said in a report published Nov. 18, 2026 that the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services does not fully identify or assess the fraud risks facing Medicare, and that its process omits assessments of how likely and how damaging those risks are.
What GAO found
CMS, within the Department of Health and Human Services, and its various contractors oversee the traditional Medicare Fee-for-Service program. CMS reported spending nearly $481 billion on benefits for about 34 million Medicare beneficiaries in 2025.
To manage fraud risks, CMS uses the Vulnerability Management Process within its Center for Program Integrity (CPI). GAO said that process is broader in scope and does not fully reflect the range of fraud risks facing Medicare.
Based on its review of Inspector General reports, GAO identified fraud risks affecting Medicare that CPI did not identify or assess as part of the process. GAO said that leaves CPI missing opportunities to mitigate fraud risks before they materialize into significant fraud.
Where the process falls short
According to GAO, the process does not align with other leading practices: it does not include an assessment of the likelihood and impact of fraud risks, and it does not examine the suitability of existing mitigating fraud controls for Medicare.
GAO pointed to supplier enrollment screening as an example. CPI identified a vulnerability associated with the supplier enrollment screening process, which GAO identified as a significant fraud risk given its association with cases of alleged Medicare fraud, but CPI's risk assessment did not assess the likelihood and impact of that vulnerability as a fraud risk.
In its summary of the findings, GAO said medical equipment suppliers could potentially circumvent the program's enrollment screening process, leaving it susceptible to fraud.
Why Medicare is on the High Risk List
Medicare has been on GAO's High Risk List since 1990. GAO attributes that to the program's size, complexity, effect on the federal budget and health care sector, and continued susceptibility to fraud, mismanagement and improper payments.
GAO was asked to review HHS's efforts to prevent and minimize fraud in Medicare. For the report, it reviewed documentation on Medicare risk assessments and related guidance, analyzed HHS Inspector General reports and federal court documents, and interviewed various contractors and HHS offices, comparing what it found against its Fraud Risk Framework and internal control requirements.
Recommendations and HHS's response
GAO made four recommendations to HHS, all listed as open. They include establishing a mechanism for CPI to effectively and regularly report identified Medicare fraud risks and corresponding antifraud efforts to the Assistant Secretary of Financial Resources, and finalizing CPI's Medicare Fee-for-Service Risk Management Framework guidance, which is currently in draft.
GAO also recommends that CPI update, complete and finalize its draft risk assessments and vulnerability summaries, and that it update its Vulnerability Management Process Overview Document to include designing and regularly performing comprehensive fraud risk assessments consistent with leading practices and internal control requirements.
HHS agreed with three recommendations and did not agree with one. GAO said all four remain valid, as discussed in the report.
What to do
- GAO recommends that HHS establish a mechanism for CPI to regularly report identified Medicare fraud risks and its antifraud efforts to the Assistant Secretary of Financial Resources.
- GAO recommends that CMS ensure CPI finalizes its draft Medicare Fee-for-Service Risk Management Framework guidance, consistent with leading fraud risk management practices and internal control requirements.
- GAO recommends that CPI update, complete and finalize its draft risk assessments and vulnerability summaries, consistent with those leading practices and internal control requirements.
- GAO recommends that CPI update its Vulnerability Management Process Overview Document to include designing and regularly performing comprehensive assessments of fraud risks facing Medicare.
Key facts and where they come from
- CMS reported spending nearly $481 billion on benefits for about 34 million Medicare beneficiaries in 2025.
CMS reported spending nearly $481 billion on benefits for about 34 million Medicare beneficiaries in 2025.
- CMS uses the Vulnerability Management Process inside its Center for Program Integrity to manage Medicare fraud risks.
CMS uses the Vulnerability Management (VM) Process within the Center for Program Integrity (CPI) to manage fraud risks.
- GAO says that process is broader in scope and does not fully reflect the range of fraud risks facing Medicare.
However, this process is broader in scope and does not fully reflect the range of fraud risks facing Medicare.
- GAO identified fraud risks, drawn from Inspector General reports, that CPI had not identified or assessed in its process.
based on its review of Inspector General reports, GAO identified fraud risks affecting Medicare that CPI did not identify or assess as part of its VM Process.
- The process does not assess how likely fraud risks are or how much impact they would have, nor whether existing anti-fraud controls are suitable.
the VM Process does not include an assessment of the likelihood and impact of fraud risks or examine the suitability of existing mitigating fraud controls for Medicare.
- CPI flagged a supplier enrollment screening vulnerability that GAO called a significant fraud risk, but did not assess its likelihood and impact.
CPI’s risk assessment did not assess the likelihood and impact of this vulnerability as a fraud risk.
- GAO says medical equipment suppliers could potentially get around enrollment screening, leaving Medicare open to fraud.
we found that medical equipment suppliers could potentially circumvent the program's enrollment screening process—leaving it susceptible to fraud.
- Medicare has been on GAO's High Risk List since 1990.
It has been on our High Risk List for federal programs that are especially susceptible to fraud, mismanagement, and improper payments since 1990.
- GAO's first recommendation is a regular reporting mechanism from CPI to the Assistant Secretary of Financial Resources.
establish a mechanism for CPI to effectively and regularly report identified Medicare fraud risks and corresponding antifraud efforts to ASFR
- GAO also wants CPI to finalize its draft Fee-for-Service risk management framework guidance.
ensure that CPI finalizes its Medicare Fee-for Service Risk Management Framework guidance that is currently in draft
- HHS agreed with three of GAO's four recommendations and disagreed with one.
HHS agreed with three recommendations and did not agree with one recommendation.
- GAO says all four recommendations remain valid despite HHS's partial disagreement.
GAO maintains that all four recommendations remain valid, as discussed in the report.
